After the birth of their son Jeremy, Eleanor and Sam Ireland are told they wont be able to have anymore children. Not willing to give up their dreams of a big family, they consider adoption. When Eleanor sees the picture of a newly orphaned little girl in the newspaper she is struck by her beauty and they bring her home with the intention of adopting her.
But Eve, as she's named, has behavioral issues which include compulsive lying, stealing toys from other children, and abusing the dog. When she's found to have stolen an expensive ring from a jewelry store Eve jumps into the river in an attempt to make Eleanor worry about her as punishment for uncovering her theft.
Trying desperately to help Eve with her issues, Eleanor has been driven to the brink of a nervous breakdown in just a month and Sam insists the child must go back to the orphanage as they are not equipped to handle her. Eve is not happy by this decision and swears revenge on the family.
Not long after the couple goes to another orphanage and adopts ten year old Nance. Nance is an awkward looking child which causes her to be continuously overlooked by prospective parents. But Eleanor falls in love with her at first sight and she soon becomes Nance Ireland, the beloved daughter of Sam and Eleanor Ireland.
Nance and the fourteen year old Jeremy quickly fall into the rolls of brother and sister but as they become adults and after spending time apart at college they find themselves in love and engaged, to everyone's delight.
One night, a few weeks away from the wedding, the young doctor Jeremy receives a call from a young woman at a hotel complaining of a sore throat. Once there the beautiful Eve greets him and admits there is no sore throat. She is simply new in town, lonely, and wants him to introduce her around.
Annoyed at first Jeremy quickly becomes amused by Eve's trick, partly because he is awestruck by her beauty. He invites her to join outings with him and Nance, including double dates, but each time him and Eve end up in their own little world, alienating Nance.
Nance is becoming worried about Jeremy's straying heart so close to their wedding day and so is Eleanor who, upon hearing the name Eve, knows in her heart it is the same Eve from her past. Eleanor did not give up Eve easily, she has spent all the years since then blaming her self for not being able to help Eve, thinking it was her inadequacy as a mother that was the problem. Often she has thought of Eve and wondering what has become of her.
When Jeremy brings Eve over to meet his parents Eleanor's intuition is proven correct and, when the two women are left alone, Eve makes no secret of her bitter hate for Eleanor. Eleanor tells Jeremy who Eve is and that she has clearly come back to get her promised revenge but Jeremy, in his male ignorance, refuses to believe someone as beautiful as Eve could ever do anything wrong.
Nance decides to go to New York for a week and stay with her Aunt Kit. Despite her colorblindness Nance has become a successful artist and creates children's book illustrations for a company in New York. Her boss, Rolph, has been pushing her to meet deadlines for a big contract and working in New York would make this easier as well and give her and Jeremy some time apart.
Once there she finds the company has taken on more contracts and Rolph tells her she will either need to work on her honeymoon or postpone the wedding. Nance sees this as a way to test Jeremy's feelings; see how he responds to the idea of postponing the wedding. To Nance's disappointment Jeremy instantly accepts the postponement and Nance remains in New York another week.
As Jeremy begins to miss his nightly calls Kit encourages Nance to accept some dates from Rolph and not wait by the telephone. She does this and at a party she finds out Rolph's friend, Steven Raymond, is Eve's ex-husband. In the past year she married and divorced Steve solely to get a hundred thousand dollar settlement from him.
Feeling the need to go back home and fight for her man Nance plans to take the train home the next morning. As she's about to head out the door her father calls asking her to come home immediately. Jeremy and Eve have eloped and the news has caused Eleanor to have a breakdown.
Taking care of her mother occupies Nance's thoughts and helps her get passed the initial shock of being jilted. When Eleanor has recovered enough Nance goes back to New York where she has decided to live.
Nance pines away for Jeremy hoping that his marriage to Eve wont last but Aunt Kit gently reminds her that even if Jeremy was to become single, it doesn't mean he would come back to her. Aunt Kit has previously been married but after her husband was killed in world war one she shut out the idea of any other relationship and has lived alone for decades, something which she regrets. She tells Nance she's happy with her life but wouldn't wish it for her.
Nance decides to start accepting dates with Rolph who has been a patient and understanding friend to Nance despite being in love with her himself. When Nance decides to visit her parents he comes along. On her first night there Eve calls inviting her over to bridge. Knowing Eve is looking to hear Nance painfully decline, she joyfully accepts.
Eve is stunned upon seeing Rolph but doesn't mention to Jeremy about having known him in the past. During the bridge game Eve cheats making everyone uncomfortable. When an emergency call comes in summoning Jeremy to the hospital Eve tries to claim Jeremy isn't home which causes a fight between the newlyweds.
Jeremy soon learns Eve often claims he's not home to keep him from his professional duties. This has caused him to lose the respect and friendship of many of his peers as well as a chance at being made chief of staff.
When Jeremy goes to New York for work he stops by Kit's and ends up going out to dinner with Nance. His unhappiness is visible and he's beginning to look worn down.
Despite promising not to withhold his calls anymore, Eve does and it results in the death of a child patient. Having had enough, Jeremy tells Eve he wants a divorce but she denies him one, threatening to have Nance sued for alienation of affection if he tries to proceed with it.
Jeremy becomes visibly depressed and isolated from his family which wears on his parents. His father, worried and depressed over his son, loses the mayoral election.
After visiting for Christmas and seeing the state her parents are in Nance decides to move back home. Once back in her social circles she learns just how much the town has come to despise Eve and Jeremy.
Come February Eve becomes ill with pneumonia. It's not serious but she does remain in the hospital receiving penicillin injections, and after going in and out of delirious sleep she awakes finding herself in love with Jeremy. She decides to confess her love and explain her past.
After returning to the orphanage from the Ireland home she continued with her problematic behavior which got her sent off to reform school. This she also blamed on the Irelands. Once out of school she began working as a maid but quickly grew unhappy with work she stole two diamond clips from her employer and ran away. The law caught her quickly and she was sent to prison for a year. Once out she went to secretarial school to acquire a position where she would meet successful men. This being how she met Steve Raymond. She married him to get enough money to head back towards the Irelands and set her plans for revenge in motion.
She confesses that her obsession with the family centered on Nance and how she deeply hated the girl and wanted to hurt her. But after getting Jeremy and causing the family so much unhappiness her obsession with Nance was not assuaged and she tried her best to ruin Jeremy's life, her goal being to have his medical license revoked. Eve says she'll do anything to prove her love for Jeremy including giving him a divorce.
After moving back home, Rolph comes to visit Nance several times with him suggesting they get married on his last visit. Nance takes some time to think it over but declines, accepting that she is still in love with Jeremy and would rather be alone if she can't be with him.
When a rainstorm comes on Nance decides to go for a walk in it, playfully jumping in puddles along the way. As she nears the bridge over a river, the same river Eve had jumped in as a child, she finds Eve, dressed in a thin coat and slippers, contemplating jumping into it once again.
Worried about her health as she had recently been released from the hospital, Nance rushes her home and into a warm bed. However Eve's health does not recover and she succumbs to a relapse of pneumonia. After her funeral Jeremy closes house and takes off for several months, ending up in Canada. Immediately upon his return he takes Nance for a drive where he apologizes and suggest they move to Canada to have a fresh start. But she insist they stay in town and, together, they will work to rebuild Jeremy's reputation.
- Okay, let's address the elephant in the room. The brother/sister thing is weird even if they're adoptive siblings. I don't understand why that was the setup, couldn't they have been neighbors that grew up together and fell in love as adults, or even a blended family wouldn't be so bad. It was a very strange choice.
- My notes simply say "Jeremy bad". He is simply a bad person whose self-centeredness caused harm to all of his family and eventually himself which is totally his karma. He didn't have to marry Nance if he had fallen for Eve but dear god, at least tell her it's over instead of eloping behind her back. It annoyed me that Nance took him back in the end.
- The outdated view of a man cheating was irritating. Jeremy's cheating is blamed on Eve for seducing him and Nance for not holding her man.
- Talking would have prevented most of the problems. Eleanor talking to the kids about Eve, Eve talking to Eleanor about her pain of being sent back to the orphanage, Jeremy talking to Nance about his attraction to Eve, Nance talking to Jeremy about her worry for their relationship.
Despite the strangeness of it this book was actually very good. It's very dramatic which at times felt exhausting but it was an attention grabber.
This book is available to read online for free but I bet you'll never guess where . . . the Google newspaper archives. This book was printed, a chapter a day, in the Beaver Valley Times newspaper starting on October 6, 1952.
Here's a link.